Separation of Church and State Home Page

The Northwest Ordinance cannot be read as a commentary on the First Amendment

Accommodationists make much of the fact that the Northwest Ordinance was reenacted by the same Congress that finalized the language of the First Amendment. Indeed, accommodationists seem to read the Northwest Ordinance almost as a commentary on the First Amendment, as if one could get some sense of the meaning of the Amendment by looking at the Ordinance. But this is to flatly distort history. Below, we present two reasons why the Northwest Ordinance cannot be used to make inferences about the framer's beliefs about church/state relationships.

The Northwest Ordinance was passed before the First Amendment was ever discussed by Congress.

The Northwest Ordinance was not written by the framers.

Return to home